Brog's Blog

August 9, 2010

“We Wish the Jews a Most Hearty Welcome Home”

Filed under: All Posts — brogsblog @ 4:02 pm

As summer extends into yet another steamy week, it’s tempting to continue our stroll through Israel’s history.  The present hate and threats will be waiting for us in plentiful supply next week.  So let’s return to the hopeful early dreams of Zionism and optimistic early days of Israel.  In reviewing what could have been, we might just see the path forward more clearly.

Last week, I wrote about the original Zionist goal of building a Jewish homeland in which the Arab residents would be full and equal citizens.  These early Zionists dared to dream that the Arabs might even welcome the Jews home and recognize in their return a source of great benefits and blessings.  Together, these Zionists hoped, Jews and Arabs could build an outpost of cooperation and prosperity that would lift the entire Middle East.

As we all know, these expectations eventually proved to be naive in the extreme.  Yet what few people remember anymore is that the initial Arab reaction to the Zionist movement was not at all hostile.  In fact, Arab leaders originally responded to Zionism as warmly as Herzl and the other early Zionists had hoped.  Rejection was not the only path the Arabs could have followed.  There were other views.  There was another way.

In 1906, Syrian author Farid Kassab noted that, “The Jews of the Orient [Israel] are at home.  This land is their only fatherland.  They don’t know any other.”  The Mufti of Jerusalem (the predecessor to the genocidal Hajj Amin Husseini) participated in the laying of a foundation stone for the Hebrew University in Jerusalem.  After Lord Balfour’s declaration that Britain would facilitate the building of a Jewish national home in Palestine, a Gaza sheikh stated, “Tell Balfour that we in the South are willing to sell him land at a much lower rate that he will have to pay in the North.”  Indeed, Arabs throughout the country sold their land to Jewish buyers without hesitation, and pocketed ever increasing profits.

Emir Feisal I (right) and Chaim Weizmann (also wearing Arab dress as a sign of friendship) in Syria in 1918.

But the most promising response of all came from the very top.  The earliest leader of the Arab national movement was Emir Faisal ibn Hussein of Mecca, a descendant of the prophet Mohammed and the leader of the Arab Revolt against the Ottoman Empire.  As Faisal directed the effort to create an independent Arab nation in the lands formerly controlled by the Ottomans, he did not see the Zionists as rivals.  He instead viewed them as potential partners in building a modern Middle East.

In 1919, Faisal led the Arab delegation to the Paris Peace Conference that followed World War One.  There he met with Chaim Weizmann, who was representing the Zionists.  The two leaders did not fight, shout, or even stare at each other icily.  Instead, they signed a Treaty of Friendship.  In this agreement, both parties pledged the “closest possible collaboration” in building their future Arab and Jewish states.  The Arabs further agreed to “encourage and stimulate immigration of Jews into Palestine on a large scale.”

In a letter to a group of American Zionists a few months later, Faisal went even further.  He wrote, “We Arabs, especially the educated among us, look with the deepest sympathy on the Zionist movement.  Our deputation in Paris is fully acquainted with the proposals submitted yesterday by the Zionist Organization to the Peace Conference and we regard them as moderate and proper.  We will do our best, insofar as we are concerned, to help them through.  We will wish the Jews a most hearty welcome home.”

“We wish the Jews a most hearty welcome home.” The fact that the leader of the Arab nationalist movement once uttered such a phrase is astonishing, but true.  And thousands of Jewish and Arab souls cry out from their graves in righteous anger that this sentiment never crossed from words into action. Actually, millions of Jewish souls cry out from their graves.  Had the Jewish national home been implemented back in 1919, millions of European Jews would have had somewhere to go as Hitler’s grasp grew ever tighter around them.

Faisal would go on to be King of Syria, and then King of Iraq.  But less visionary leaders later seized control of the Arab nationalist movement.  In time — and as a response to the Zionist movement — the local Arabs began to view themselves not as Ottoman subjects, and not even as Arabs in a broader sense, but as a distinctive new nation — Palestinian Arabs.  In a very real sense, Palestinian Arab nationalism was the offspring of Zionism.  And as if possessed of a powerful Oedipus complex, Palestinian nationalism has been trying to kill its Jewish father ever since.  With limited exceptions, Palestinian leaders have embraced the path of war and rejection, including the rejection of repeated offers to create a Palestinian state.

Given what could have been, the present state of affairs is pure tragedy.  But it is important to note that there was another path.  And it is even more important to stress that this path still exists.  Yes, it may be covered by the desert sands, but it’s still there and it remains passable.  Anwar Sadat walked down it on his way to Jerusalem to recognize the Jewish State.  So did Jordan’s King Hussein.  And it is possible that one day a Palestinian leader will follow their lead.  Until then, Israel must continue to stand strong.  Israel must defend herself.  The ongoing dream of destroying Israel must be proven to be naive in the extreme.  Maybe then, the dream of peace will once again capture the minds of those who are supposed to lead their people.

David Brog is the executive director of Christians United for Israel and author of a new book, In Defense of Faith: The Judeo-Christian Idea and the Struggle for Humanity.  You can follow David on Facebook by clicking here and on Twitter by clicking here.



  1. ‘For if Abraham was justified by works, he has something to boast about, but not before God. For what does scripture say? ‘Abraham believed God, and it was reckoned to him as righteousness.’

    Comment by Glenn L. — August 9, 2010 @ 8:54 pm

  2. Palestinian nationalism was the direct product of a studied and consistent British Colonial policy of divide and conquer, implementing both Trans-Jordan and its British officers and officialdom in its execution: whereby both the letter and spirit of the Balfour Declaration was deceitfully betrayed for the imperialist design of uniting Syria with Palestine with the intent of exclusion first of the French, then of the Jews. So much so that within a decade,in August,1929, the one-time, initial comity of Arab and Jew (as portrayed above) had radically altered, resulting in the Mufti-directed, bloody attack on the ancient Jewish residents of Hebron, Safed,Tiberias, and the Bab Alchota quarter in Jerusalem, with the cry “ed-dowle ma’ana”/’the government is with us’. As indeed they,(professing to be “neutral”),were – right down to its “death-sentence” (C.Weizmann) White Paper of May, 1939.Into this British-made moral vacuum, Nazism took up the Palestinian cause.

    Comment by abigail — August 10, 2010 @ 12:01 am

  3. Thank you for this writing! Let us also concider all the brethern around the world being persecuted, rejected. Shalom to Jerusalem, Eretz Israel, and those out of the Nations.

    Comment by Pastor Louise — August 10, 2010 @ 8:46 am

  4. What good is lands or homes when you deny Jesus and will lose it all?

    Comment by John — August 10, 2010 @ 1:33 pm

  5. John,

    Has a point.
    That is where we spend eternity is most important. That is why our relationship with Jesus Christ is of utmost importance!

    That being said God did make earthly promises to Adam, Noah, and more specifically to Abraham, Isaac & Jacob(Israel). God also made earhtly and spiritual promises to Israel & King David.

    Early on in God’s Word; God said that those who “bless my people will be blessed and those who curse my people will be cursed”. God never removed that promise from earthly Israel. I want God’s blessings in my life and not His curses. That is why it makes a difference. To bless Israel is part of the Christian’s obeying God’s Word!

    I also believe as wild-branches us Christians are grafted into Isreal. At least one chapter in the book of Romans talks about us Gentile believers in Jesus Christ being grafted into the vine of Israel.

    Comment by Internet Pastor Bill — August 12, 2010 @ 12:12 pm

  6. Welcoming the Jews home. That would be impossible for them to do for according to their religion there was never any room for the Jews.
    There was never anything else.
    All the rest is wishful thinking right up today.

    Comment by MANNY — August 12, 2010 @ 5:31 pm

  7. Speaking as a new member, I would believe that God is working wonders that we may not perceive, but, be assured they will be to the benefit of all that follow the ways of the Lord Jesus.

    I wish them joy and bounty in the talks in DC this week, and, in the spirit of a Show Business salute to a comrad: “Break a Leg.”

    Comment by Gordon DeSpain — August 31, 2010 @ 3:30 am

  8. To amend the comment above, not only is God on their side but Jesus will return to fight with the Israelis when they need him most. He is, and, was a Jew, despite those that would wish to strip him away as their own.

    Comment by Gordon DeSpain — August 31, 2010 @ 3:33 am

  9. mmmmmmm, but you are not true Banu Israel? I mean even by DNA you are European or African who converted to religion…!!

    Comment by amonamon2 — August 31, 2010 @ 10:35 pm

  10. The only truly reliable source of information (despite our divergent opinions or prejudices) is the Jewish Bible (The Tanakh and the New Covenant/The Old and New Testaments). HaShem/The Lord Almighty is good to the humble soul who looks to Him for Life, including forgiveness, repentance, and the Holy Spirit. These are all good gifts of the Messiah who is named Yeshua. Jews and Christians are brothers and friends according to Psalm 122; we both pray for the Shalom of Jerusalem. If anyone seeks Truth and Grace (Jewish and Gentile seekers), HaShem is gracious to all…except the arrogant who will not stand in His presence because of refusal to learn about mercy and grace His Way. The Bible is quite clear in the Tanakh and the New Covenant (Jewish Law of Forgiveness and Knowing God) that the Jewish people are Chosen and Beloved. We Christians/In-Grafted Gentiles must treat them as they are seen by God (even if they don’t believe in Jesus YET). If any Jews will allow us to open up The Book with them, we can lovingly discuss the 300+ Messianic Prophecies about Yeshua. We can turn to Genesis 5 and talk about the importance of Jewish names: 1) Adam (MAN)…2) Seth (IS APPOINTED)…3) Enos (FEEBLE/MORTAL)…4) Kenan (DWELLING). 5) Mahalaleel (GOD WHO IS PRAISED)… 6) Jared (DESCENDS)…7) Enoch (TEACHING/CONSECRATING)…8) Methuselah (THAT HIS DEATH BRINGS)…9) Lamech (CAPTIVES)…10) Noah (COMFORT/RELIEF). Oh…Gentiles…love and bless the Jews and you will be loved and blessed. Instead of asking Jews to celebrate Christmas, why don’t you consider joining their Hanukkah celebration…Jesus did…(see John 10). Leave Islam (and all hateful, hurtful ideologies). Embrace ISRAEL forever for LIFE (Shalom with God, Love, Joy, and True Peace within yourself and with your neighbor)…

    Comment by Likedoves — October 6, 2010 @ 1:55 am

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Create a free website or blog at

%d bloggers like this: