Brog's Blog

April 19, 2010

Of Friends and Foes- April 12, 2010

Filed under: All Posts — brogsblog @ 8:57 pm

Earlier this month, the President of Afghanistan — Hamid Karzai — lashed out against the United States.  Although he is widely reported to have won his reelection through fraud, he made the absurd claim that the international community was to blame for any voting irregularities.  Although he owes his power entirely to the U.S. and allied troops fighting the Taliban for him, he dared to criticize his defenders.  Invoking the Taliban’s claim that US forces are invaders and not liberators, Karzai noted that “In this situation there is a thin curtain between invasion and cooperation-assistance.”  A few days later, it was widely reported that Karzai threatened to quit the political process and join the Taliban if he continued to come under U.S.  pressure to reform.

Let us remember that, to date, over one thousand United States soldiers have given their lives to support Karzai’s government from Taliban advances.

How did the Obama administration respond to this disturbing display of ingratitude?  By all accounts, they have decided to back away from their pressure on Karzai.

Over the weekend, the New York Times ran  a front-page story under the headline “US Takes Softer Approach Towards Afghanistan’s Karzai.”  And on Sunday, Obama Administration officials demonstrated this new, softer approach through their comments on the Sunday news programs.  Rather than criticize Karzai, Administration officials expressed sympathy for the pressure he is under both politically and militarily.  Defense Secretary Gates noted that its only natural for a political leader to “react strongly” when he feels his nation is being pressured or disrespected.  General Petraeus stressed that “President Karzai is the commander in chief — he is the president of a sovereign country.”

I mention all of this not to criticize this response.  We may well have backed ourselves into a situation where we cannot afford to alienate Karzai, no matter how offensive he is.  I will leave this to the Afghanistan experts.  What angered me about this turn of events was the way in which our treatment of Afghanistan and President Karzai casts into sharp relief our shabby treatment of Israel and Prime Minister Netanyahu.

Let’s remember the following.  Prime Minister Netanyahu won in an open and honest campaign.  No one can accuse Israel of holding rigged elections.  Although he has been pressured and disrespected by the US, he has never “reacted strongly” against our country or the Administration.  And although Netanyahu also faces domestic political pressures and foreign threats, he has largely complied with the demands made upon him by the Obama Administration.  He has agreed to embrace a two-state solution to the conflict with the Palestinians.  And he has issued an unprecedented 10-month freeze on construction in Israeli settlements.

Far more than Afghanistan, Israel is a sovereign country not dependent upon outsiders for its existence.  Indeed, let us never forget that Israel fights its own battles.  The Israelis are proud of the fact — as they should be — that they have never asked American boys to shed their blood in her defense.  Instead, Israeli soldiers are the ones who fight and die to preserve Israel’s freedom.  All Israel asks is that they be free to defend themselves by themselves.

Despite all the above, what was once merely a whisper campaign has become increasingly difficult to deny.  President Obama does not much like Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu.  After Netanyahu announced that Israel would proceed with a plan to build housing in an established Jewish neighborhood in East Jerusalem, Vice President Biden and then Secretary of State Clinton issued rare public statements of condemnation — something that does not happen without a green light from the White House.

More recently, President Obama agreed to meet with Netanyahu while the Prime Minister was in Washington.  But there were no joint appearances, and no photo opportunities.  In the midst of their discussions, President Obama departed to eat dinner with his family.  Our President left Prime Minister Netanyahu behind with instructions to continue working as if he were a member of the President’s staff rather than the elected leader of one of our closest allies.

Israel isn’t always right.  Differences between the White House and the Israelis are neither new nor shocking.  But recent events only highlight a troubling diplomatic double standard.  Our treatment of Israel is a marked departure from the deferential treatment accorded the most ungrateful of our allies, not to mention some of our enemies.  As Americans we have every right to criticize this approach and demand better from our President.  We will continue to do exactly that.



  1. Excellent!

    Comment by Molly Magnus — May 5, 2010 @ 1:20 pm

  2. It boggles my imagination the audacity of Obama and his crowd in telling Israel when and where they build, live or anything else. He seems to think he is the great I AM.
    May the LORD preserve us HIS people


    Comment by Myrtle Linder — May 11, 2010 @ 12:53 am

  3. Thank you for your support and saying it like it is.

    Comment by R. Swartzberg — May 11, 2010 @ 1:03 am

  4. I am so glad to see truth written….I miss that in this country….truly miss it. So thank you….Israel is probably the only true democracy left in the world and her people are dedicated to her…guess that’s probably why she’s hated. All we seem to want to win anymore is a popularity contest with all the wrong factions….not to mention….it’s true that darkness cannot face light..and as Israel continues to grow in light…we are decending ito darkness…I pray we wake up, or I’m sure the nightmare is just going to increase ….
    Brenda K. Chandler

    Comment by Brenda — May 11, 2010 @ 3:01 am

  5. President Obama and his administration are insidious and nothing like they presented themselves prior to election. I hope the majority of people are waking up. This is a disgrace.
    Very good article.

    Comment by Jean Terry — May 12, 2010 @ 11:26 pm

  6. Thankyou for your inciteful article.

    When I saw Obama in Europe during the Pres. Campaign referring to himself as the hope of the world and watched his campaign speeches which I would call a ‘Dialogue in Smoke & Mirrors’
    I found him to be charrismatic though shallow and without substance.

    Then his questionable associations I was shocked from my country to the north (Canada) to see the masses running blindly to vote for him as though he were some rock star or something. I saw him for what he was, due to my studies in world politics and religions, as a marxist.

    Socialism, Marxism and Communism are one in the same.

    So then when I see Obama bowing before Arab Princes and then apologizing for America;I was not surprised to see Obama’s dismissive attitude toward the Israeli Prime Minister as Atheists and Believers in God do not mix just as Darkness cannot stand against Light.

    If and when the Muslims & Communists come against Israel then look up as God will fight for His Chosen People.

    It is my hope that the American Electorate will wake up and turn back to the principles the country was founded on and vote the evil out of office.

    Comment by glenna hall — September 21, 2010 @ 2:47 am

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Blog at

%d bloggers like this: